Home State Supreme Court to pass orders on mechanism for CCTV cameras at police...

Supreme Court to pass orders on mechanism for CCTV cameras at police stations to check abuse


New delhi: In a bid to examine violation of human rights at police stations throughout the nation, the Supreme Court on Tuesday mulled over a CCTV mechanism ‘to place the system straight’ and stated that it’s going to cross orders on the problem.

A bench of Justices RF Nariman, KM Joseph and Aniruddha Bose which reserved its verdict on the problem stated that the CCTV footage of the police station must be preserved for not lower than 45 days and a mechanism have to be there to retailer it.

“We will have to pass orders which will ultimately put the system straight,” the bench stated.

The prime court docket, whereas coping with a matter associated to custodial torture, in July this 12 months revived a 2017 case wherein it had ordered the set up of CCTV cameras in all of the police stations to examine human rights abuses, videography of crime scene and organising of a Central Oversight Committee and such a panel in each state and Union Territory.

At the outset, senior advocate Siddharth Dave, appointed as amicus curiae within the matter to help the court docket, advised the bench that a number of states have filed affidavits highlighting compliance of prime court docket’s order handed on April 3, 2018, within the 2017 case.

He stated that Madhya Pradesh has put in 859 cameras in 1117 police stations, Mizoram has put in 147 CCTVs in 40 police stations, Manipur has put in 87 CCTV cameras whereas Sikkim has put in two CCTV cameras in prisons and never in police stations.

The bench stated that it wants further affidavit from the states on whole variety of police stations in every district and need to see that the CCTVs put in are functioning and duty needs to be mounted.

Dave replied {that a} Station House Officer (SHO) needs to be made liable for the functioning of the CCTV cameras.

Attorney General KK Venugopal, whose help was sought by the court docket within the matter, stated that state governments ought to guarantee electrical energy and web is made obtainable to those police stations situated in rural areas for easy working of CCTVs and a questionnaire additionally must be circulated for getting all related data.

The bench stated, “We are on police atrocities and what is more important is that the oversight committee should be able to take a look at these CCTV footages and take immediate action.”

Senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, showing for West Bengal advised that the oversight committee can comprise of police commissioner, district Justice of the Peace and superintendent of police.

He submitted that every one the police stations within the state are outfitted with CCTVs and state authorities will type an oversight committee after dialogue with the Chief Minister.

Additional Advocate General of Uttar Pradesh, Vinod Diwakar additionally stated that state has ensured CCTV cameras set up in all of the police stations.

The bench stated it’s good that some states have complied with the instructions however the court docket will not be on particular person matter and is holistically.

Advocate Yogesh Kanna, showing for Tamil Nadu stated that the state has a coverage of placing up cameras in all vital stations to which the bench stated, “The most unimportant places will become the most important as the accused will be thrashed there.”

Venugopal advised {that a} helpline to the oversight committee must be put in place in order that any atrocities being dedicated could be dropped at mild instantly.

The bench stated it’ll cross orders in a day or two and requested Dave to submit a written notice of solutions by November 27.

On July 16, the highest court docket had sought response from the middle and states on the problem of bigger questions of audio-video recordings of part 161 statements of the accused earlier than the police in addition to the bigger query as to the set up of CCTV cameras in police stations usually.

It had famous the April 3, 2018 order wherein it had stated that in each state an oversight mechanism be created whereby an unbiased committee can research the CCTV digicam footages and periodically publish report of its observations.

On August 5, the highest court docket had stated it want to know the precise place as to CCTV cameras in police stations in addition to the structure of oversight committees in accordance with our order dated April 3, 2018 within the 2017 case.

It had issued discover to Chief Secretary of every state and Union Territory on questions- “What exactly is the position with respect to CCTV cameras fitted in each and every Police Station in the State or Union Territory and what is the position qua constitution of Oversight Committees in accordance with our order dated April 3, 2018? “

The prime court docket had stated that it expects that the Chief Secretary of the states and Union Territories to take this matter significantly and in proper earnest because it entails the basic rights of the citizen below Article 21 of the structure of India.

Read Full Article